Understanding Medicare Plan Star Ratings: A Guide For Agents

As a new Medicare agent, you’re navigating the essentials of Medicare plans and looking for ways to best support your clients.

One critical piece of the puzzle is understanding Medicare’s star ratings, a tool developed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to assess the quality and performance of Medicare Advantage and Part D plans. Star ratings can significantly influence a client’s choice, so knowing how they work—and how to communicate their importance—can position you as a knowledgeable, trusted advisor.

This guide provides you with an in-depth look at star ratings, what they represent, and how to use them effectively in your conversations with clients.

What Are Medicare Star Ratings?

Medicare star ratings are a system created by CMS to measure and compare the quality and performance of Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Prescription Drug (Part D) plans. These ratings, which range from 1 to 5 stars, are published annually based on a variety of performance metrics.

Each star rating reflects the level of care, customer satisfaction, and overall service that a plan provides, with 5 stars being the highest. Ratings are calculated using data from surveys, plan performance reviews, and health outcomes, ensuring that the evaluation is comprehensive and based on multiple factors.

The Ratings for 2024 Include:

Excellent – 5 Stars

Above Average – 4 Stars

Average – 3 Stars

Below Average – 2 Stars

Poor – 1 Star

Why Are Star Ratings Important for Agents?

Star ratings provide a quick snapshot of a plan’s quality, helping clients make informed decisions. High-rated plans tend to have fewer complaints, better customer service, and higher client satisfaction, all factors that can directly impact your clients’ healthcare experiences.

Moreover, clients who enroll in high-star plans are often more satisfied, leading to greater retention rates. Agents benefit because satisfied clients are more likely to stay with their current plans and with their agents. Star ratings can also influence commissions; some insurance carriers incentivize agents who enroll clients in 5-star plans.

How Low Star Ratings Impact Medicare Plans: 

• It’s also helpful to understand the implications of low star ratings, especially when a plan has fewer than 3 stars. Plans with consistently low ratings (below 3 stars for three consecutive years) are labeled as “low-performing” by CMS and may be at risk of termination if improvements aren’t made. Discussing the risks of low-rated plans can help clients avoid potential issues with service or coverage.

How CMS Calculates Star Ratings

Star ratings are based on a wide range of performance measures that fall into several key categories. Each of these categories includes specific metrics to evaluate how well a plan performs.

Customer Service:

• Measures the quality of a plan’s customer service, including handling member inquiries, appeals, and complaints.

Member Experience:

• Surveys from current members gauge satisfaction with the plan and overall experience.

Managing Chronic Conditions:

• Evaluates how well the plan supports members with chronic conditions, like diabetes or heart disease, including the provision of services and preventive measures.

Preventive Care:

• Measures plan performance in delivering preventive services such as screenings, vaccines, and wellness visits.

Pharmacy Services (for Part D plans):

• Looks at prescription services, including medication adherence and ease of access to necessary drugs.

Each plan receives an individual score in these categories, which are then combined into an overall star rating. High performance in multiple areas will contribute to a better star rating, while underperformance can bring the rating down.

How to Present Star Ratings to Clients

When discussing star ratings with clients, it’s essential to keep the conversation straightforward and to explain the ratings’ significance in terms they can easily understand.

Explain the Basics:

• Start by explaining that star ratings are a simple way to compare plan quality. Use an analogy, like a restaurant rating, to help them understand that higher stars mean better quality and satisfaction.

Connect Ratings to Client Priorities:

• Highlight areas that are important to your client. For example, if they’re concerned about managing chronic conditions, point out how star ratings measure a plan’s effectiveness in managing chronic diseases.

Be Transparent About Limitations:

• Not all high-rated plans are perfect fits for every client. Emphasize that while a 5-star rating indicates high quality, the plan’s benefits, network, and costs must still meet their specific needs.

Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs) for 5-Star Plans

A unique benefit of 5-star plans is that they offer a Special Enrollment Period (SEP), allowing Medicare beneficiaries to switch to a 5-star plan once per calendar year outside the usual enrollment periods. This is particularly valuable for clients who may be unhappy with their current plan but missed the annual enrollment period.

By offering clients this SEP, you’re helping them potentially access higher-quality care sooner, reinforcing the value of star ratings and improving client satisfaction.

Factors to Consider When Recommending Plans

While star ratings are essential, they’re only one factor to consider when recommending plans to clients. Always balance star ratings with the client’s needs, lifestyle, and budget. Some clients may prioritize low premiums or extensive provider networks over a high star rating, so make sure you’re considering their unique needs. Use the following checklist when advising on plan choices:

Review Star Ratings First:

• Use star ratings as an initial quality indicator.

Examine Plan Costs:

• Look at the premium, copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles.

Check the Provider Network:

• Confirm that preferred doctors and hospitals are in-network.

Assess Drug Coverage (for Part D plans):

• Ensure the plan covers their prescriptions.

Discuss Client Preferences:

• Understand if they prioritize customer service, provider access, or specific health benefits.

Ultimately, your goal is to empower clients with information. Star ratings provide a reliable indicator of a plan’s quality, but they’re only part of the picture. Encourage clients to ask questions, consider different plan aspects, and weigh their priorities.

Understanding Medicare’s star rating system is invaluable for new agents who want to give their clients an edge in choosing the right plan. Remember these key points:

• Star ratings provide a benchmark for plan quality.

• 5-star plans offer an SEP, making them more flexible.

• Use star ratings as part of a broader assessment of client needs.

Mastering the star rating system helps you guide clients toward plans that fit their preferences and health needs, establishing you as a knowledgeable and caring advisor! 

 

Contact a Fidelis Sales Director to Learn More!